So turns out that I've received a lot of questions around Mac vs PC from family and friends who have kids going to college this fall. I also interview students for the college I went to and this question comes up (specially after they see me using a MacBook Pro to do the interview). I figured I would capture some of the thoughts on the topic and provide my take in the matter. This by no means is meant to be a comprehensive look at the options that are out there. If you are interested, there are
plenty of discussions out there.
Off the bat, I usually recommend the
11" MacBook Air and undoubtedly the first thing I get back is "but they are so expensive". I figured I would look at the numbers and see how it would pan out. The comparison is against an
HP machine which is the cheapest I found in OfficeMax.
There's also the question of
iPad (w/ bluetooth keyboard) vs full laptop. I believe students still benefit from a full laptop (I'm thinking about writing those 40 page papers and gamers). I'm willing to be proven wrong, though.
Here's what I came up with:
| Feature |
MacBook Air 11" |
PC |
| Price |
$899 (typically there's a 10% discount for students) |
$399 |
| Weight |
2.38 pounds |
5.5 pounds |
| Screen Size |
11.6" |
15.6" |
Office Productivity
Suite (1) |
$59.97 |
$149.95 |
| Anti-Virus (2) |
Not needed |
$159.96 (you have to renew virus license every year) |
| Memory |
2GB |
4GB |
| Processor |
1.6 GHz Dual Core |
1.6 GHz Dual Core |
| Storage |
64 GB (flash drive; up to 2x-4x faster) |
500 GB |
| Backup |
$0 (Time Machine included) |
$80 (typically $20 / year) |
| OS Upgrade (3) |
$29 (at least the last 2) |
$119 (at least that's what it was for Win 7 Home Premium) |
| Battery Life |
Up to 5 hours (30 day standby) |
Up to 5 hours |
| Screen Resolution |
1366 x 768 (up to 2560 x 1600 w/external monitor) |
1366 x 768 |
|
|
|
| Total |
$987.97 |
$907.91 |
(1) You could save by using the free versions of Office like Symphony or OpenOffice . I'm assuming students will need a word processor ($19.99 for Pages), spreadsheets ($19.99 for Numbers), and presentations ($19.99 for Keynote). If students only need a word processor, Pages is enough and it's ~ 1/8 the price of MS Office)
(2) Some colleges have a site license for anti-virus. Used Symantec Anti-Virus at $39.99 / yr. Update 3/Aug/2011: Apparently, Microsoft has a free solution for anti-virus. Not sure how good it is or how it compares to the paid ones.
(3) I'm assuming that in 4 years Apple will release another update to their OS and Microsoft will release one as well.
So the Mac is costing you about $80 more over a 4 year period. Yet, it's about 2 pounds lighter and it's up to 2x faster. Personally, I would recommend the 13" MacBook Air which would come up to about $1258 over 4 years (vs $907.91 for a PC). The 13" MacBook Air gives you 7 hours of battery, it's still under 3 pounds, a 128GB SSD of storage, and has a faster processor at 1.7 GHz.
Of course, cost is not the only consideration. Some tools will only run on a Windows environment so it might be good to ask current students in the prospective major what they are using.
There you have it. Hope this helps.